Island Tradition Since 1949
Welcome to Frosty's Bar, a beloved Put-in-Bay landmark where cold beer, fresh pizza, and unforgettable memories come together in the heart of downtown.
Family-Owned Excellence
Since 2007, Kim and Ryan Stoiber have continued our tradition of hospitality, leading our dedicated team of seasonal staff in creating memorable experiences.
Classic Entertainment
Challenge yourself to our vintage video games while enjoying the jukebox's classic rock tunes in our nostalgic atmosphere.
Team Frosty
Founded in 2003, Team Frosty competes in Florida Keys tournaments, spreading our renowned name and spirit beyond Put-in-Bay.
Signature Frosty Mugs
Our iconic frosty beer mugs deliver the coldest, most refreshing draft beer on the island.
Fresh Pizza
Savor our made-to-order pizzas, baked fresh and perfect for sharing with friends.
Harbor Views
Enjoy beautiful views of DeRivera Park and Put-in-Bay harbor while dining with us.
Island Community
Join our community of natives, boaters, and visitors who make Frosty's their favorite island destination.
